In the legal world, the term “overrule” has two distinct meanings. The most commonly used interpretation involves a superior court judge overturning or reversing a decision made by a lower court judge. In this case, overrule refers to a higher court or judge assuming a “superior” position with regard to the decision in the case.
The second meaning of overrule has to do with laws, or presupposed states of fact, that take precedence over ordinary laws. For example, in the United States, the U.S. Supreme Court can “overrule” any federal law or decision from a lower court through their judgment in constitutional cases. Such decisions take precedence over existing laws and rulings, changing the way a particular case is approached. This type of overrule can also be used to invalidate laws or decisions that are deemed to be unconstitutional or in violation of an individual’s rights.
Understanding Overrule in Practice
One of the most famous examples of an overrule being determined by a higher court is the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, a decision that reversed the 1896 ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson. In Brown v. Board of Education, the Supreme Court found that segregated public schools were in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment and established a new legal precedent that said separate was not equal. The Brown v. Board of Education case would go on to transform the way public education is approached in the United States.
So, to sum it up, overrule generally refers to a decision by a higher court or authority that overturns or supersedes a lower court decision or existing law. In the legal world, the term “overrule” can have a large impact on the way a case is argued or, in some cases, the way a particular branch of law is interpreted.